Product Review: Halo Top Creamery Lemon Cake All Natural Light Ice Cream

Halo Top Creamery Lemon Cake All Natural Light Ice Cream
Halo Top Creamery Lemon Cake All Natural Light Ice Cream

Product: Halo Top Creamery Lemon Cake All Natural Light Ice Cream – $5.49+

So…a couple weeks ago I posted my first blog on my first flavor of Halo Top Creamery All Natural Ice Cream.  It was the vanilla flavor…and save for some not-so-creamy texture…it ranked high in my book!  What’s not to love about an ice cream that has fantastic flavor, dishes up like ice cream, and is low in calories and high in protein?  There is SO much to love about that…let me tell you!

So, I was sort of (okay…maybe a little more than sort of) excited about dishing up a bowl of the other flavor that my roomie and I decided to pick up that day there was a special on them at our natural food store.  I chose Vanilla Bean.  She chose Lemon Cake.  This shouldn’t surprise anyone…as she is a lemon freak!  Like…freaky freak over lemon.  Like Rick James Superfreak over lemon.  I mean…I love lemon too, but she takes her lemon love to a new and somewhat disturbing extreme.  HA!

Recall…the Halo Top Creamery Vanilla Bean All Natural Light Ice Cream had amazing flavor, but was less creamy than regular ice cream.  It wasn’t bad through and it didn’t fall apart and flake when dished.  It still rolled up perfectly in the ice cream scoop and made pretty little balls of ice cream in my bowl.

Well…tonight…it was the Lemon Cake flavor’s turn to shine.

We polished off dinner (Gluten-Free and Vegan BLATs [vegan bacon (made with black beans and buckwheat groats…yes…I make it myself!), lettuce, avocado, and tomato sandwiches) with grilled corn-on-the-cob.  I asked if she wanted ice cream of cookies for dessert.  She had no opinion…and I didn’t care.  Since we had the ice cream longer than the cookies…I opted for the ice cream.  Besides, she has a cold and up until this morning a sore throat…so ice cream is the best remedy for that, right?  Of course!

I pulled it from the freezer, got my 1/2 cup measuring cup out (yes…I portion-size everything!), ice cream scoop, and ice cream bowls.  I was ready to dish.  The ice cream scoop went into the pint…and it flaked.  It flaked!!  It didn’t roll up into the scoop.  It busted up into little ice cream like pieces…and crumbled.  The result was a bowl of ice cream that looked more like scrambled eggs than ice cream.


So…the texture on this one was WAY off.  But…what about the flavor?

On the Web site, the Halo Top Creamery Lemon Cake All Natural Light Ice Cream is described as being not too sweet and not too sour.  It states that it has the perfect amount of zesty freshness and sweet richness.  And it’s called Lemon Cake because it has a “smooth cheesecake-y texture.”

*eyes scrambled egg-like ice cream in bowl*


Okay…the flavor was actually a very delicate and enticing blend of lemon flavor.  It wasn’t overwhelming…but Cathy didn’t even realize she was eating the Lemon Cake Halo Top Creamery Ice Cream.  I mentioned it after and she said, “That was the lemon cake?”  I don’t know what to say about that…because she also is fighting a cold.  To me…the lemon flavor was actually spot-on.  It wasn’t overpowering but it wasn’t too under-the-radar either.  It had great flavor.

But…my GOD…it was not at all ice cream-like.  More like…sorbet gone wrong.  And it’s too bad.  It really is too bad because I had such high hopes for the Halo Top Creamery Lemon Cake All Natural Light Ice Cream.  If you don’t mind flaky, crusty ice cream…then this is for you.  But, it is called ice cream for a reason.  And this…was not the texture I was hoping for when I bought it.


The Halo Top Creamery Lemon Cake All Natural Light Ice Cream is made up of milk and cream, cultured non-fat milk, cage-free eggs, whey, erythritol, organic cane sugar, chicory root, casein protein, acacia gum, sea salt, organic lemon peel, organic lemon oil, organic sunflower oil, organic carob gum, organic guar gum, carrageenan, and organic stevia.

As for nutrition…a serving of Halo Top Creamery Lemon Cake All Natural Ice Cream is 1/2 cup.  This serving dishes up only 70 calories and 3 grams of fat.  A serving also gives you 43 mg cholesterol, 89 mg sodium, and 4 grams of sugar.  This 1/2 cup serving will also provide you with 4 grams of fiber and 7 grams of protein.  Not bad.

Too bad the ice cream is not good…

This was a huge disappointment.  I wanted to try all the flavors, but this sort of made me not want to waste my money.


A “scoop” of Halo Top Creamery Lemon Cake All Natural Light Ice Cream

3 Replies to “Product Review: Halo Top Creamery Lemon Cake All Natural Light Ice Cream”

  1. It still looks good to me! Have you tried Block Shaved Ice? it looks like lichen/moss but it is still sooo good. I’ve learned long ago, don’t trust a food item by how it looks… it’s usually the most delicious!

  2. Mine was out for a while (accidentally after a trip to the food store) but I thought it was really very good. The consistency was good and the taste was light and sweet with just the right amount of lemon.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: