Restaurant: Annie May’s Sweet Café, Louisville, Kentucky
I don’t know how I didn’t know about this place sooner. Well…I actually found out about it months ago and have been following their Twitter feed, hearing about the gluten-free goodies that they are whipping up, not just in their bakery, but for breakfast and lunch too. Why it took me this long to check them out probably had to do with me putting my foot down and saying that this year I really didn’t want to bake my own birthday cake. Because, let’s face it…no one should have to bake their own cake.
That was what lit a fire under my roommate and she made a call to Louisville’s only completely gluten-free, soy free, peanut free, and tree nut free bakery. Even better, upon request, most items can also be made without egg and/or dairy products. Living in this area with food allergies just got a lot more delicious.
You see, the owner of Annie May’s Sweet Café, Annie May McGill, was diagnosed with a gluten intolerance back in 2009. What grew out of that was a mission to create amazing allergy-free recipes. She is joined by Kenna Nelson, a pastry chef who was also a Biology major. She finds the chemistry behind gluten-free baking fascinating and from this pair…Annie May’s Sweet Café grew. By 2010, Annie May’s was a wholesale delivery service. And a year later, their current shop opened up. And thank the gluten-free gods for them. Annie May’s mission is to provide desserts that taste so good, you wouldn’t even be able to guess that they are gluten-free. Let me tell you…mission accomplished. In fact, the recipes that she developed over the years taste so amazing, many of the customers who visit or frequent Annie May’s Sweet Café don’t even have food allergies. Food that good is worth opening a shop for. In addition to the small selection of goodies in the bake case each day, Annie May’s also offers a dine-in eating option. And, you can place an order on anything and customize it as you need.
Once again…how did I not get to this place until now?
I guess I just needed to have my birthday roll around. And when it did, my roommate made a call and ordered me a simple 6″ Strawberry Cake with a Vegan Chocolate Ganache icing. Nothing fancy, you wouldn’t think. Just a simple gluten-free cake that myself and her family could enjoy after my birthday lunch. I actually did a happy dance of joy when she came over to my office and told me she had just placed an order with Annie May’s Sweet Café for my birthday cake. I had to wait until Saturday, the day of the lunch with her family, for the cake, but…I could do it. Of course, all week it was all I talked about and I totally couldn’t wait to go and pick it up on Saturday morning.
Anticipation makes the week move slowly, but Saturday morning arrived. After going for a very short run (I was running a 1/4 Marathon on Sunday morning), Cathy and I hopped into the car and drove over to Louisville to get some morning coffee, pick up my race packet, and…finally set foot in Annie May’s Sweet Café. Coffee was first, and we did that in rather quick time at our new favorite local spot in Louisville. From there, it was time to hit up the bakery.
As we drove up Frankfort Avenue…we missed the little corner shop at first. I spotted it as we drove by, actually. So, we turned around and came back, parking and preparing for our first visit to Annie May’s.
As we stepped inside, there was a large group of people around a table, drinking coffee and enjoying some food. I skipped up to the counter with Cathy, who let the lady behind the counter know we were picking up my birthday cake. As she went to go get it, I began scoping out the bake case. Everything looked so delicious. I was drooling. And, the cereal I ate for breakfast was now long gone…and the café smelled so good. I think Cathy felt the same way because she said we should get something to eat.
Much rejoicing.
It just so happened that Annie May’s had a delicious looking selection of Pumpkin Doughnuts done four ways – Maple Glazed, Chocolate Ganache, Cinnamon Glazed, and Cinnamon Sugar. I was in heaven. First a birthday cake…now allergen-free and vegan pumpkin doughnuts. Pardon me while I pull a Wayne’s World here and bow down to both Annie May and Kenna and chant, “We’re not worthy! We’re not worthy!” Well, since there were doughnuts involved we each had to get one. I went with the Cinnamon Sugar Pumpkin Doughnut ($2.49) and Cathy opted for the Chocolate Ganache Pumpkin Doughnut ($2.49). They graciously packed them up in a box, we paid, tipped, and headed out to the car.
And then…the cop moment of the day happened. I was sitting in the parking lot of Annie May’s Sweet Café with my Pumpkin Spice Almond Milk Latte from Highland Coffee, noshing on a gluten-free pumpkin doughnut. Life had never seemed so good than that moment. I eagerly opened the little box that cradled the doughnuts in paper. I handed Cathy a napkin and her chocolate ganache covered doughnut. Then I grabbed mine and eagerly took a bite.
OH. MY. GOD. The gluten-free doughnut gods were smiling on me that day. These were beyond fantastic. These were beyond amazing. These topped Katz Gluten-Free Donuts (because these didn’t have to be frozen…these were fresh and you could tell). These were one of the best doughnuts I had ever eaten. The consistency was that of a normal cake doughnut. It had that heavy, filling feel to it. The flavor was tops. I loved the sweetness of the added cinnamon and sugar on the outside of it. It was soft, chewy, and sooooooooo delicious. Cathy was making happy noises as she noshed on the chocolate ganache version. And, of course, we each broke off a piece of ours to share with the other. Let me tell you…the chocolate ganache pumpkin doughnut was out of this gluten-free world. The chocolate added a kick of rich sweetness that blended so well with the cake-like doughnut that it coated. I loved it. Seriously.
So, if the doughnuts were any indication of what would happen with my cake…I was riding high on gluten-free cloud nine. We left Annie May’s Sweet Café, resisting the urge to go back in for more doughnuts…although the temptation nearly won us over. After a quick swing by Slugger Field to pick up my race packet, we headed back home with the cake…and a lot of growing anticipation to cut into it. But lunch had to happen first. And so…it did.
Afterwards, however, we all congregated back at our apartment for gifts and goodies. Goodies being…a slice of my 6″ Gluten-Free Strawberry Cake with Chocolate Ganache Icing ($20.00). I opened up the box and was just wowed by the cake. And that was before even slicing into it. It looked beautiful. No corners were cut. Annie May’s took great care and even wrote Happy Birthday Karen on it in delicious vegan icing. Seriously…they are artists there. They have to be, because my cake was one of the most beautiful desserts ever presented to me. Especially since I had to go gluten-free. I almost cried.
Cathy and Amanda took on the task of dressing up my cake with candles. And after I made a wish and blew them out…I went into the kitchen and began to slice into this gluten-free birthday masterpiece. This 6″ round cake is meant to serve 8 people. We had five. So, I cut pieces accordingly. And when I scooped out the first sliver…I was wowed. Not only was this cake a work of art on the outside…it was also one on the inside. Layers of strawberry cake with the vegan chocolate ganache greeted me. It was just beautiful. I cut out slices for everyone, then settled in on the living room floor with a fork and took my very anticipated first bite.
If Heaven were a birthday cake…it would look and taste like this one. In fact, I hope Heaven is a birthday cake that looks and tastes like this one. The strawberry cake itself was loaded with flavor. Often times, strawberry cakes can fall short when it comes to taste, but not this one. The cake was moist, bright pink, very strawberry (my favorite fruit, by the way), and not heavy or dense. And the vegan chocolate ganache was to die for. Rich with chocolate flavor, it coated each layer and made an amazing icing for the cake. Yeah…Heaven better be a lot like this cake because it sure as hell (heh…pun) tasted like Heaven to me. For the next couple of days, my roommate and I got to enjoy a couple more slices, making me one very pleased birthday girl.
I was beyond impressed by the quality and care that goes into the goods at Annie May’s Sweet Café. Honestly. The doughnuts were a great way to get a first impression. But the birthday cake they made for me was the chocolate-coated icing on the cake (literally!). I am so impressed that Annie May’s is now going to become a frequent stop on our trips over to Louisville on the weekend. Why? Because I love to support local businesses, even more when they cater to dietary restrictions like what I have. I want to try everything in their bake case. I want to stop in for their dine-in food and give everything they make a try. They didn’t just make me a gluten-free birthday cake…they made me one of the most delicious cakes I have ever eaten a slice of. No exaggeration. It beats out anything I had before I was diagnosed as gluten intolerant. It made me want to order a cake just for the hell of it. Sort of that need to try everything. Start working down the list.
I will resist…but I won’t keep myself from going back in and getting more goodies from the bake case. There is plenty of amazing allergen-free goodies to go around and for me to sample. For now, I thank Louisville for this gem of a business. It has definitely just made my list of favorite spots to go in Louisville. And…being right in my backyard, I sense that my Saturday mornings just got a lot more delicious.
Thank you, Annie May’s Sweet Café for making my birthday special…and for keeping an allergen-free business where I know I can safely enjoy the food and goods that you serve. I am forever in your debt.
And you better believe I’ll be back.
Now…excuse me while I go and sing your praises once more to everyone…
The Celiathlete 
One Reply to “”